Guide
Repair or replace a furnace?
There is no single cutoff age. Weigh the repair, the furnace's track record and your plans for the house.
Questions that settle most cases
- Is this the first real repair in years, or the third this winter?
- How large is this repair compared with what a new furnace would cost?
- Has a contractor found a crack in the heat exchanger? That is a safety issue, and most owners replace.
- Are parts still made for this model?
- Are rooms uneven or the bills high even when it works?
- Will you sell soon? Some suburbs inspect at sale. See below.
When repair makes sense
An igniter, a flame sensor, a capacitor or an inducer motor on an otherwise sound furnace is normally worth fixing. These are parts designed to be replaced over the life of the unit.

When replacement is the better spend
A cracked heat exchanger, a failed control board on an old furnace with other worn parts, or a string of visits in one season are where the arithmetic tips toward new equipment. So is a plan to add central air, since the coil and the furnace work together.
The replacement page covers the choices in detail.
Selling in Cleveland Heights or Shaker Heights
Both cities inspect houses before sale. In Cleveland Heights, HVAC appears in the city's list of Class A violations, and an uncorrected major one can mean an escrow at 125 percent of the average repair cost. Shaker Heights sets its point-of-sale escrow at 150 percent of the estimated repair.
A failing furnace on a house about to be listed is worth settling early.
What makes a repair or a replacement cost more
Price factors
- Parts that must be ordered rather than pulled from the truck.
- After-hours or holiday visits, if the contractor charges for them.
- Venting changes and a chimney liner on a replacement.
- Duct and return work.
- Higher-efficiency, two-stage or modulating equipment.
- Permit and inspection.
Furnace out, or the central air quit?
Ring the number below. An independent HVAC contractor serving Cleveland and its inner-ring suburbs hears out the problem and sets up the visit with you.